Why are Men like that? Their Emotional Ineptitude explained

Using your roommate as an access point to bed a friend of his, breaking up with your partner because she’s not inspiring or splurging on bad investments you believe could make you happy, all of these stories are real, definitely not unique and each one exposes a different ugly side of manhood, but they are all tied to one common factor, Male Emotional Ineptitude.

Over time, I think we accepted men for what they are and can never be, their tantrums, outlandish business ideas and disgraceful treatment of others are being acquitted with a shrug and a sigh. How would you even change something as domineering as a tank with the awareness of a log? And do they know why they suffer? Are they even aware of their suffering in the first place? 

In order to understand the complex machinery that has emotionally neutered the men who wander this world, we need to know more about what they are suffering from, which boils down to three factors : Emotional Self-Awareness, Emotional Regulation, and Mentalization.

 

Emotional Self-awareness

Many men are unaware of their own emotions, because growing up, emotions are ruled to be feminine and thus weak, unfit to be displayed by a man. However, most men don’t know what emotions are or why they are important. According to James Lange, emotions are an evolutionary adaptation, that premeditates an action by putting the body into a specific state. One good example for this is the sentiment of fear. In this logic, a hiker encountering a bear is not scared because she sees the animal, but because her body is preparing to flee. 

Not everyone has seen a bear in their lives, neither has everyone eaten the wrong mushroom, but the things that trigger our basic emotions are the same ones that kept our ancestors alive, they act as a built-in radar for the sensible course of action of our forebears. Thus, every emotion has an adaptive quality, and ignoring them makes life not only more difficult, but also more dangerous.

The five basic emotions of Anger, Fear, Joy, Disgust and Sadness function to keep us alive. Other, more complex emotions like Shame have a social purpose, that facilitates life within a group, which was and still is essential for survival. 

If a person shows no remorse and doesn’t make amends after committing a transgression against rules within a group, they are exiled, which would be a death sentence in our primordial past, demonstrating that Emotional Self-Awareness is an adaptive tool, crucial for survival, one which men are taught neither to use, nor to cultivate, at the expense of their own life satisfaction.

 

Emotional Regulation

Feeling emotions is one thing, but sometimes the premeditated action does not help with your goal. When you are offended by your partner and get angry, the emotion of anger prepares the body to physically attack, but this is useless at best and detrimental at worst in a wordfight. What is important in these situations is to regulate the emotion you are feeling and thus alter the actions the body would prepare for via the emotion.

This skill is vital for everyday life, be it among friends, in school or at work, there will always be situations, where a mismatch between the felt emotion, and the sensible action occurs, so that you don’t do the wrong thing in the wrong place.

Strategies for emotional regulation are as varied as there are people, but for the previously described situation, where you got angry at the words of your partner, one strategy that often works is withdrawing briefly and making deep breaths to activate the parasympathetic nervous system, which is responsible for resting and digesting. In this context, it would calm the emotions of the affected person and allow them to interact with their significant other, without their body anticipating a physical attack.

Because emotions are treated as a taboo among men, only the fewest of them have sound strategies for emotional regulation, and often either rely on their romantic partners to do that for them, or completely avoid it at all. This not only creates an unhealthy dependence on their close ones in some men, but also leaves them more prone to being swayed by their sometimes maladapt emotions.

 

Mentalization

When you mentalize, you are imagining the mental state and emotions of another person or yourself in the past or future. Mentalization is a key skill for social interaction, because it allows a person to make a decision based on the emulated mind of their counterpart.

This ability is also crucial for the cognitive development of children and can be used as an indicator for neurodevelopmental disorders like Autism Spectrum Disorder.

Mentalization is sort of the pinnacle of emotional skills in my opinion, because if used properly, it allows a person to deduce the most fit response in any social interaction. Imagine you’re taking a test and you already know all the answers because you can imagine them and you’re correct most of the time, this is almost too good to be true. 

Sadly, many men don’t practice mentalization, and the least of them use it habitually, which helps explain why so many of them behave awkwardly in novel social situations. I believe that is because the patriarchal framework, which we all grow up in, and which raises us all racist and sexist, prohibits men from feeling and recognizing their emotions, thus inhibiting any recognition of their own emotions, which is a prerequisite if you want to imagine the mental states and feelings of other people.

In total, men generally lack Emotional Self-Awareness, which blocks Mentalization and Emotional Regulation skills. This results in maladapt choices and social dependencies as well as growing isolation and a barren inner life.

 

Why is that?

When I was six years old, I had my first consciously sexist thought. I was watching TV with my mother, a segment was on about Evanescence, and it was then that I thought to myself „if women are weak and not allowed to do so many things, why is she allowed to be the lead singer of a band?“ 

Looking back, it would be embarrassing to say out loud today, but this also serves as proof of how norms can be learned and applied, and it is directly linked with the reason why most men are emotionally inept.

Boys and men are taught that women are inferior to them, and that any association with women or anything that is part of womanhood, is detrimental to their person. This norm probably originated in post-neolithic world, where humans became sedentary because of agriculture and roles became segregated based on sex rather than age or skill as it was previously, since now women were required to churn out workers which could be used to create surplus value, so the family could make it through winter. This was probably unpopular with women, prompting men to subjugate them into control. This subjugation then transformed into implicit rules and codes that defined the role and status of a person by their genitals, before they could even display interest in anything.

Because most emotions are associated with women, and women are inferior according to patriarchal logic, boys are taught not to feel or recognize their own emotions in order not to appear weak to their peers.

This means boys and men are permanently locked in an imaginary PR-contest amongst each other, where the goal is to appear strong and not lose face by appearing weak. This game is played by putting strong masculine behaviors on display outwardly, like feats of athleticism, while hiding or even suppressing weak feminine behaviors, like crying, to avoid losing face.

This means that every man in the world is consciously or unconsciously trying to be the manliest man according to his own norms and those of the men he respects. This means that many men see emotions as feminine and weak, and therefore never developed any emotional skills. It sounds almost silly if you think about it, most men don’t use their built-in radar for social interactions because they are scared of people thinking they’re a woman.

 

Men and their Friends

One of the consequences this has on the health of men is in their interpersonal relationships with their friends. Most men forge friendships from habit and shared spaces, people from their local gym, their classes or work. And despite some valiant efforts, a man has yet to hate women enough to forsake his need for friendship, which means, they still need to find ways to become friends and to maintain those links. 

But, because the inner life of another man is about as taboo as one’s own, they have to resort to other dynamic subjects, like Politics, Football, and War. Many men have nuanced opinions on those subjects, but couldn’t give the same level of detail on the inner life of their most trusted friend. These discussion topics serve as a stand-in or replacement for the dynamic aspect of your own feelings and your friends’, allowing men to bond over shared experiences and attempts at solving problems. However, these worldly dynamic subjects are not as efficient at creating and deepening bonds as emotional conversations are. 

Men would maybe relate to one another over favor for a player or attempt to imagine together what type of foreign policy could change the country for the better, but neither of these ideas have the capacity to influence their own lives. Other people would for instance bond over a break-up and exchange coping strategies or talk about their emotions to find healthy ways of managing seasonal depressive symptoms, both strengthening connections and finding ways to change each other’s lives for the better.

It is because of those deeply impersonal friendships that men often need a shared activity and can’t spend two hours talking with their friends. In the digital age, conveniences offered by electronic devices made many mundane activities obsolete, reducing the environments where men would meet, and where their friendships would form and thrive, which is the root cause of the male loneliness epidemic.


Not women choosing themselves over men, it has always been them.

 

What Now?

In conclusion, most of the suffering men endure nowadays is due to a lack of emotional skills and a desolate inner life, which stems from sexist conditioning all throughout their existence and leads to impersonal friendships, increasing risks of depression, social isolation and cardiovascular disease. 

As a genderqueer person, I absolved the entire parkour of male socialization, only to choose an alternative later on, so I have a unique perspective on this problem and hope any man reading my thoughts can learn something from them. In the instance where a man does want to put in the work to suffer less from his lack of emotional skills, I recommend two sets of imagining what someone else feels, sees and thinks each day, and employing at least one healthy emotional regulation strategy per week.

 

Sources

  • Carel van Schaik/ Kai Michel, Die Wahrheit über Eva

  • Bret Weinstein/ Heather Heying, A Hunter-Gatherer's Guide to the 21st Century: Evolution and the Challenges of Modern Life

  • “Sciences Affectives” course, UNIL, Spring Semester 2026

  • My own thoughts

  • Header image : https://ch.pinterest.com/pin/182536591122980583/sent/?invite_code=55ce01d174274344ba32e0f6fc075710&sender=1127096381652255874&sfo=1

 

Culture

L‘inconscient chez Carl Jung

Avez-vous déjà pu penser que vous étiez plus que ce que vous êtes ? Je veux dire, vous êtes déj&agrave…

Matthieu Sahli ·